On October 9, 2025, two federal courts examined President Trump’s US National Guard deployment to Democratic-led cities.
Chicago and San Francisco hearings questioned the necessity and legality of these actions.
Chicago Judge Questions Claims
In Chicago, Judge April Perry challenged Trump’s claims of violent protests justifying the US National Guard deployment.
She sought clarity on the troops’ role, expecting a decision later that day.
San Francisco Court Skepticism
A San Francisco appeals panel doubted Oregon’s argument that Trump overstepped his authority in Portland’s US National Guard deployment. Judges questioned whether past protests justified the current presence.
Democratic Governors Protest
Governors of Illinois and Oregon accused Trump of exaggerating peaceful protests to justify the US National Guard deployment.
They argue it targets political opponents rather than addressing real threats.
Chicago Facility Tensions
In Broadview, Chicago, National Guard troops patrolled an immigration facility.
Protesters, facing tear gas and rubber bullets, fear escalation from the US National Guard deployment, prompting a local police probe.
Judge Probes Mission Clarity
Perry expressed concerns over inconsistent explanations. Government lawyers cited officer safety, but Trump claimed crime control.
This ambiguity fuels debate over the US National Guard deployment’s purpose.
Portland Deployment Challenged
In San Francisco, Oregon’s Stacy Chaffin argued Trump’s orders lack grounding.
However, Judge Ryan Nelson said courts shouldn’t micromanage troop needs, complicating the US National Guard deployment case.
Trump’s Broader Plan
Trump vowed to expand the US National Guard deployment to cities like Chicago and Memphis.
He claims it counters “left-wing terrorism,” targeting groups like antifa, despite their decentralized nature.
Legal Limits on Troops
US law restricts National Guard involvement in civilian policing. Trump’s orders test these boundaries, raising concerns about the US National Guard deployment in Democratic strongholds.
Protester Concerns Grow
In Broadview, protester Will Creutz, 22, braced for escalation. “I’m ready for worse,” he said, citing prior injuries.
The US National Guard deployment heightens tensions at the facility.
Court Orders Limit Force
A Chicago judge issued a temporary order restricting federal agents’ use of force against protesters.
This responds to injuries reported during the US National Guard deployment protests.
Afro Nation Portugal 2026 to Electrify Algarve with Top Stars
